8 Unique Places to Stay Around Ohio's Lake Erie Shores & Islands - Cutler Blog
July 12, 2019 |

8 Unique Places to Stay Around Ohio’s Lake Erie Shores & Islands

When you think “beach vacation,” Ohio isn’t usually on the top of the list — but it should be! Lake Erie, which spans Ohio’s entire northern border and stretches all the way to Buffalo, New York, boasts pristine sandy beaches, lush surroundings, nearby vineyards and plenty of unique spots to take it all in. Regardless of the season, a vacation to Lake Erie is always a great idea.

We rounded up some of our favorite spots all around Ohio’s Lake Erie shores and islands to escape to that offer distinctive experiences — from massive Caribbean-esque resorts to charming inns. So no matter what type of vacation you’re looking to book, we’ve got something for you on this list. Happy exploring!

A Water’s Edge Retreat Luxury Inn

827 East Lakeshore Drive, Kelley’s Island

Lake Erie Hotels

A Water’s Edge Retreat Luxury Inn is one of the most talked about Lake Erie destinations — and for a good reason! This idyllic Victorian house is right on the beach and offers amazing, unobstructed views in all directions. All of the guest rooms are elegantly decorated and feature all of your favorite modern conveniences like private bathrooms and air conditioning. Before you spend the day walking or biking around the island, make sure to stop in for their famous breakfast held in the beautiful formal dining room every morning!


Captain Montague’s Bed & Breakfast

229 Center Street, Huron

Located in the small beach town of Huron, Ohio, Captain Montague’s offers the perfect juxtaposition of Old World charm and modern luxury. The building itself was once the home to Captain C.Z. Montague and his family in the late 1800s and still has many of the original features — including a handcrafted black walnut staircase and the exquisite original wood flooring. Each of the gorgeous rooms has been completely restored and offers cozy spaces to escape to after a long day on the water!


Hotel Kilbourne

223 West Water Street, Sandusky

Hotel Kilbourne is Sandusky’s first boutique hotel located on the city’s beautiful historic waterfront. The adorable, Instagram-worthy rooms are full of luxurious touches like cozy bedding, appliances and stunning views of either the city or the breathtaking waterfront. We recommend this quaint hotel not only because of its fantastic amenities, but also its central location close to Sandusky’s downtown entertainment scene, the beach and Cedar Point ferries.


Firefly Beach Resort

4903 Cleveland Road East, Huron

Photo courtesy of Firefly Beach Resort

A quintessential beach destination, Firefly Beach Resort offers over five acres of private grounds for your summer vacation. Stay in their tiny, colorful cottages or park your RV on their large camper space — no matter where you stay in the resort the beach will be only a few feet away. And if you get hungry during your waterfront relaxation session, pay a visit to the Erie Kai, the onsite restaurant that serves up fresh fish, grilled sandwiches and other delicious dishes.


Milan Inn-Tiques

29 East Church Streets, Milan

Milan Inn-Tiques is located on Milan’s Village Square close to the Edison Birthplace Museum and several other historic destinations. Downstairs, peruse for gems in their antique store, enjoy the colorful murals in the “Edison Room” and take a break at the Coffee Station. And if you’re looking for a truly unique place to stay in Milan, there is a one unit room for rent upstairs that can sleep up to 10 people! The cozy apartment features, of course, antique decor along with modern amenities like a TV, full kitchen, wireless internet and a laundry space.

Coastal Floating Homes

545 West Lakeshore Drive, Port Clinton

Why should you settle for being near the water when you could literally be on the water? Well, we’re happy to tell you that you can, indeed, stay right on Lake Erie in a Coastal Floating Home! These one-to-two-bedroom homes are floating on the water, with a boat dock at your door. As an added bonus, each home offers a fully equipped kitchen, washer and dryer, satellite TV and are located just steps from downtown Port Clinton and ferry service to the Lake Erie Islands.


Cedar Point’s Castaway Bay Indoor Waterpark

2001 Cleveland Road West, Sandusky

Places to stay near Lake Erie

Photo courtesy of Cedar Point’s Castaway Bay Indoor Waterpark 

For a fun, family vacation, there’s no better place to stay on Lake Erie than Cedar Point. Not only can you have a blast at the famous amusement park and the beach right out front, but the Castaway Bay Indoor Waterpark brings the fun right to your hotel with a wave pool, water coaster, slides and so much more. Plus, in your resort, you’ll also find a fitness center, arcade and several fantastic restaurants!


Islander Inn

225 Erie Street, Put-in-Bay

This Caribbean-style hotel is a vacationer favorite in Put-in-Bay offering the best of Lake Erie’s natural beauty and the feeling of an exotic vacation at the same time. Throughout the resort, you can find four huge pools, a 30-person jacuzzi and two swim-up bars. So spend your days lounging by the water with a drink or rent a golf cart from the hotel and explore the historic island!


Have a Fun Vacation!

No matter where you’re planning on spending your vacation days, we hope you have a blast!

Cutler Marketing Team

More Posts by

Leave a Comment